Ironically,
the MOOC phenomenon has given rise to the phrase “rock star professors”, or
“superprofessors”. No offense to any
college professor is intended, but it made me laugh. Rees (2013) has described superprofessors as
the prominently known professors who lecture in some of the most popular MOOCs
currently available through companies such as Coursera and EdX. The curriculum materials created by these
rock stars are viewed in some cases by tens of thousands of students in a
single academic term. Furthermore, due to
recent developments, in some situations the curriculum materials created by
these superprofessors are spreading beyond the boundaries of a single online
platform, to the traditional brick and mortar classrooms of various institutions
nationwide. These superstar professors
have the opportunity to devise curriculum materials that could potentially reach
farther than ever previously thought possible.
A potential
wide scale implementation and acceptance of MOOCs within the higher education
industry could potentially force the redefining of the faculty role as we
currently know it. In a traditional
course setting, professors invest a significant amount time during each academic
term creating curriculum resources and interacting with students. In this traditional format, college
professors dedicate a significant portion of their time engaging with their students,
and providing customized instruction and performance feedback. In contrast, the MOOC phenomenon has given rise
to an alternative definition of the role of the college professor. The professors that utilize the MOOC format
invest a great deal more time and resources than their traditional counterparts
in the creation of the course structure and curriculum materials. Essentially, MOOC
professors must develop all of the needed course resources at the onset of the
course. However, once the course starts, their role as
the course instructor is much more minimal comparatively. Since MOOC students have limited interactions
with their professors, and their work is usually graded by a computer, MOOC instructors
do not share the same set of responsibilities as their traditional counterparts,
and infrequently interact with students.
When
you ponder the further implementation of MOOCS on a wide scale manner, the use
of MOOCs could potentially change the role of professors beyond the digital
walls of the MOOC classroom, spilling over into the traditional brick and
mortar classroom. At San Jose State
University (SJSU), faculty members are facing pressure to integrate MOOC
courses into their existing curriculum (Kolowich, 2013). A group of professors from the philosophy
department at SJSU have united in an effort to stop the integration of these
MOOC resources within their university, claiming that they are inferior to the
traditional method of instruction, stating that this is nothing more than an
effort to replace qualified faculty with cheap online instruction. Rees (2013) provides a similar view, stating
that the MOOC phenomenon has the potential to drastically cut labor cost. It is
conceivable that as traditional institutions of higher education contemplate
utilizing MOOC resources in lieu of their traditional class materials, the onus
of creating curriculum materials could be removed from the course professor,
essentially entering institutions of higher education into the leasing business
in terms of curriculum materials. Many
within the field are worries that MOOC expansion could pose a serious threat to
the traditional role of the college professor to essentially a class moderator.
Resources
Rees, J. (2013, July 25). The
MOOC Racket. Retrieved from
http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2013/07/moocs_could_be_disastrous_for_students_and_professors.html
Kolowich, S. (2013). Why professors
at San Jose State won’t use a Harvard professor’s MOOC. Retrieved from
http://chronicle.com/article/Why-Professors-at-San-Jose/138941/
James,
ReplyDeleteI found the phrase “rock star professor” to be pretty funny as well (I’m pretty sure I’ll never be considered a rock star teacher!). I like the term you use “class moderator” in describing the potential role professors could take with wide spread MOOC use. However, in looking over MOOCs for this course and getting an idea of how extensive they are it seems conceivable that faculty members could be relegated to MOOC facilitators if conditions allowed. Your MOOC sounds great!
Ann-Marie
Hi James,
ReplyDeleteIn wondering about the number of professors in higher ed, I looked up the data after reading our articles. We have already seen the traditional tenure-trach moving toward non-tenure, which has also been a debate. Looking at the changes of the percentages or tenured to non-tenured from the 70 to present, the numbers have changed. This could very well be where the concerns are coming from -- will non-tenure begin to move to contract faculty.
The moderator aspect is odd as I would speculate students who take a MOOC for credit would expect more interactions and feedback. It is another aspect that will be interesting to follow.
James,
ReplyDeleteI had never heard the term "rock star" professors until I viewed the article. Does this state that just because someone is "well-known" his or her method of instruction is the best? However, as you mentioned the roles and responsibilites of an instructor facilitating a MOOCs is much different than the instructor in the traditional class once the course begins due to the limited interaction. Great post!
Hi James,
ReplyDeleteThanks for an interesting post! You know, I expect that rock star professors have always existed. People in a given field know who the super stars are. I suspect that technology simply makes it easier to become one, and to be recognized beyond a single field. So maybe super stars are more likely today than before. I agree that some professors are worried about this phenomenon and that it could pose a threat to traditional roles. Then again, perhaps it's time to have another look at those roles!